This week I met Ron Harari, 21, who served as a combat medic. On October 7th he was called to his base in Nahal Oz which had been infiltrated by hundreds of terrorists, creating a bloodbath of murdered and wounded Israelis. Ron began treating everyone he could and then traveled to another base to help treat the wounded there. On the way, his APC was hit by a Kornet missile, and he was thrown into the air, one arm ripped off and shrapnel in his eye. His friend, who was also in the APC, was killed instantly. Ron was rescued and airlifted to Soroka Hospital, where he was sedated and ventilated.
We recently flew Ron and several other soldiers to NY to be seen by top doctors and specialists.
When we met, I asked Ron to put on tefillin. He agreed, we proceeded to wrap the straps and he recited Shema.
Then Ron asked me, “You know I can’t put on tefillin by myself now; I only have one hand. Am I still obligated to put them on daily?”
I gave it some thought. Here is a soldier who fought and battled for Am Yisrael, and while performing the greatest mitzvah of all—saving lives—he is wounded so badly that his hand is ripped off and he cannot don tefillin.
As a rabbi, answering a question is easy, but the trick is to answer the person not just the question.
So while the surface answer was easy—”yes, you still need to put on tefillin”—the real question was much deeper and harder to answer: “Why would G-d take away my hand if He commands me to put on tefillin, which I now can’t do?”
We know that every single thing in life is Divinely orchestrated. Nothing occurs randomly. It’s all part of His heavenly plan. Sometimes we are given glimpses into that plan, but often we are not.
I had to dig deep. Ron’s question was painful and legitimate. Why would G-d take away his hand? And why would G-d take away his hand when he needs both hands to wrap tefillin every day?
And the unsatisfying answer is simply: I don’t know. I have no explanation for G-d’s actions. I don’t think anyone knows or understands. All I know is how much we love Ron and appreciate his sacrifice. And I know that we will all be there to wrap tefillin on Ron whenever he wants.
But why G-d brought him so much pain, why so many soldiers were injured and why October 7th happened … that we don’t know.
We pray for the day Moshiach comes when all will become clear and all pain will evaporate.
In the meantime, we will continue to envelope Ron with love, joy, and immense gratitude.
L’chaim, Ron! G-d loves you and so do we.