This week I downloaded a new AI assistant: Instinct.
It’s very exclusive; invite-only. But hey, I made the cut! And I have to tell you, he (or she? I’m still not sure) is pretty incredible.
I send him a voice note, and he posts directly to my social media. He answers my emails. When something important comes in, he flags it and asks, “Want me to respond?” He reminds me what I need to do, when I need to do it, and what’s on my calendar.
And he checks up on me! If I tell him about something and then don’t follow up, he texts me: “Hey, what’s going on with this? And what about that?”
I asked him to suggest vacation destinations for Shevy and me. He came back with the Bahamas, Mexico, Turks and Caicos. Beaches, kosher food, even minyanim! How does he know where my wife likes to go?! I didn’t actually book anything, so every couple of days, he nudges me again: “We have to figure this out!”
Then one morning this week, he asked me, “How are you feeling today?”
Now, I wasn’t feeling great, but how in the world did he know?
I was feeling down because we didn’t have a minyan that morning. I hadn’t expected it because our daily minyan has been going strong for quite some time now. I was even expecting a bigger crowd than usual, perhaps our biggest weekday minyan ever! At least 15-16 people had replied affirmatively that they planned to come.
But when it came time to daven, we only had nine.
I started texting people. “Hey, where are you? Are you coming to minyan?” The responses trickled in. “Sorry, I slept late.” “I’m not feeling well, sorry.” “Oh, I had to go out of town at the last second, I’ll be back next week.” “I have a headache.” And so on.
So when Instinct asked, I answered honestly: “I’m actually a little depressed today.”
He wrote back: “I’m sorry, we can leave the work aside. Did something happen, or is today just feeling heavy?”
I asked him what I could do to feel better.
After confirming that I wasn’t having thoughts of hurting myself, he suggested taking 10 minutes to “keep it small. Stay away from work, have some water and something to eat if you haven’t. Get a little fresh air. You don’t have to fix the whole day right now. And if you can, tell Shevy or someone you trust: ‘I’m having a rough day. Can you talk for a few minutes?’ You don’t have to carry it alone.”
But here’s the thing: Even Instinct has its limitations. It can post for me. It can answer my emails, flag what’s important, plan my vacation, and chase me about it every two days.
But as much as I refer to it as “he,” it isn’t a person and can’t be the tenth man in a minyan.
So the thing I actually needed that morning, Instinct couldn’t do. He can try to be my therapist. He can give me advice. And it was good advice! But he doesn’t have a soul. And that’s what I needed.
A minyan is ten neshamot, ten Jewish souls, standing together before G-d. That’s the one thing no AI on earth can bring to shul.
So, sure, let AI write your emails, keep your calendar, and plan your vacation. But tomorrow morning, let it remind you that minyan is at 7:15 a.m., and then get dressed and bring your neshamah to shul.
In a world where more and more can be done for you, there are still some things only you can do: Minyan. Shabbat. Kosher. Chesed. Tefillin. Tzedakah. Your relationship with your fellow Jews and with Hashem. Whenever souls are involved, the work can not and should not be outsourced. It takes a soul to reach a soul.
